Seeing Through the Fog: What Business Jet Crews Need to Know About EFVS, Synthetic Vision and the FAA's Rules
How FAA rule 14 CFR 91.176 treats EFVS vs. synthetic vision, EFVS-TD vs. EFVS-100, training and recency, Part 91 LOAs, and why LED lights can vanish on IR.
Winter brings fog, low ceilings and snow showers to a lot of the airports business jets use. Many modern jets carry a camera in the nose and a head-up display in the cockpit that can "see" the approach lights before the pilots can. But the rules on what that picture lets you do are specific, and they depend on the equipment, your training and the type of operation.
Here is how the FAA's rules for enhanced flight vision systems work, based on the regulation itself, the FAA's advisory circular and the Aeronautical Information Manual (AIM).
EVS, SVS, CVS and EFVS: not the same thing
The FAA defines an enhanced flight vision system (EFVS) as an installed system that uses imaging sensors, such as forward-looking infrared or millimeter wave radar, to show a real-time picture of the scene ahead, according to Advisory Circular 90-106B. To be used for an EFVS operation, that image must appear on a head-up display (HUD) or an equivalent display, together with flight symbology.
Infrared, a common sensor type, picks out objects by their heat signature, the AC explains.
Synthetic vision is different. A synthetic vision system (SVS) draws a computer-generated picture of terrain and runways from a database. The AIM, paragraph 5-4-22, says SVS "does not provide a real-time sensor image of the outside scene." A pilot "cannot use a synthetic vision image on a head-up or a head-down display in lieu of natural vision to descend below DA/DH or MDA."
A combined vision system (CVS) blends sensor and synthetic images. The AIM says a CVS can be used for EFVS operations only if all the EFVS requirements are met and the synthetic picture does not get in the way of the sensor image or the required visual references.
Two kinds of EFVS operations
The rule is 14 CFR 91.176. It creates two types of operations.
EFVS to touchdown and rollout (EFVS-TD), §91.176(a). The pilot uses the EFVS image instead of natural vision from the decision altitude or decision height (DA/DH) all the way to touchdown and rollout. AC 90-106B says this can be flown on any straight-in Category I approach with a DA or DH. Operators with a specific authorization to treat an MDA as a DA can also use it on certain nonprecision approaches. The pilot monitoring must also have a display of the enhanced image.
EFVS to 100 feet (EFVS-100), §91.176(b). The pilot uses the EFVS image to descend below DA/DH or the minimum descent altitude (MDA) down to 100 feet above the touchdown zone elevation (TDZE). Below 100 feet, the pilot must see the threshold or touchdown zone references with natural vision. The AC says EFVS-100 can be flown on any straight-in Category I precision or nonprecision approach, including those offset up to 30 degrees.
Neither type can be flown on an approach with circling minimums, the AIM says.
What you must see, and when
Under §91.176, the pilot must first determine that the enhanced flight visibility seen through the EFVS is not less than the visibility on the approach chart. From the DA/DH down to 100 feet, either the approach light system or both the runway threshold and touchdown zone must be "distinctly visible and identifiable" on the EFVS.
The AIM stresses a point pilots sometimes miss: the EFVS does not lower the minimums. "The DA/DH or MDA and the visibility value specified in the IAP to be flown do not change," it says. The EFVS simply gives the pilot another way to meet the visual requirements below minimums.
If the image or visual references are lost, or any EFVS component fails in the visual segment, the AC says a go-around should be initiated.
Training and recency
Any pilot conducting an EFVS operation needs a logbook or training record endorsement for an FAA-approved ground and flight training program, under 14 CFR 61.66, according to the AC. Ground training applies to the pilot in command, the pilot flying and the pilot monitoring. Flight training applies to the PIC and pilot flying.
For Part 91 pilots, recency works much like instrument currency. Within the prior six calendar months, the pilot must have logged six instrument approaches using the EFVS, one ending in a full-stop landing. A completed approved course or check also counts. If recency lapses for more than six calendar months, only an FAA-approved EFVS refresher course restores it, the AC says.
Authorization: Part 91 vs. Part 135
AC 90-106B says Part 91 operators need a letter of authorization, known as LOA C048, to conduct EFVS-TD operations. They do not need an LOA for EFVS-100 operations in the United States, though one can be issued to satisfy a foreign authority.
Part 91K, 121, 125 and 135 operators need operations specifications or an LOA for both types, the AIM says. Their pilots keep current through EFVS tasks in their recurring checks. Certificate holders can also be authorized for "EFVS operational credit," which lets them dispatch or begin an approach in lower reported visibilities based on the sensor's demonstrated performance.
A winter trap: LED lights
Many airports are swapping incandescent bulbs for LEDs. The AIM warns that "LED lights cannot be sensed by infrared-based EFVSs." Airports with LED approach lighting are flagged in the Chart Supplement with the remark "Pilots conducting EFVS ops; be aware LED ALS in use."
On a foggy approach, that means the lights you expect to see on the HUD may not show up. Check the Chart Supplement during your briefing, not at minimums.
The bottom line
Before you rely on the camera, confirm what your aircraft is approved for in the Airplane Flight Manual or its supplement, check that your training and recency are current, and know whether your operation needs an LOA or operations specifications. The FAA's EFVS page and AC 90-106B are the place to start.
Sources
- eCFR: 14 CFR 91.176, Straight-in landing operations below DA/DH or MDA using an enhanced flight vision system (EFVS) under IFR
- FAA Advisory Circular 90-106B: Enhanced Flight Vision System Operations (May 2, 2022)
- FAA Aeronautical Information Manual, Chapter 5, Section 4 (5-4-22 Use of Enhanced Flight Vision Systems on Instrument Approaches)
- FAA Flight Standards: Enhanced Flight Vision Systems (EFVS)